On the night of Friday 29 November 2013 the Clutha, a much-loved music pub on Stockwell Street close to the river, was busy, with a band playing. At about 10.22pm a Police Scotland helicopter fell from the sky onto the pub’s flat roof, which partly collapsed into the crowded bar below. Ten people died and more than thirty were injured. It was one of the worst nights in Glasgow’s modern history, and the city’s response to it has never been forgotten.
The flight
The helicopter, a Eurocopter EC135 operated for Police Scotland by Bond Air Services, had taken off from the Glasgow City Heliport at 8.45pm on a police tasking. On board were the pilot, Captain David Traill, a former RAF helicopter pilot, and two police officers working as observers, PC Kirsty Nelis and PC Tony Collins. As the helicopter returned across the city, both of its engines stopped, and it came down onto the roof of the Clutha.
The ten who died
All three people on the helicopter were killed. Seven people who had gone to the Clutha for a Friday night out also lost their lives: Gary Arthur, Joe Cusker, Colin Gibson, Robert Jenkins, John McGarrigle, Samuel McGhee and Mark O’Prey. Six died at the scene, and one of the seriously injured died in hospital on 12 December. They were sons, fathers, partners and friends, and they are remembered by name.
Running towards the building
What the city remembers alongside the loss is what happened in the minutes after the crash. People inside the pub and passers-by on Stockwell Street went towards the building rather than away from it, forming lines to help the injured out through the dust and darkness while the emergency services arrived. Their courage, and the work of the police, firefighters, paramedics and hospital staff, became part of how Glasgow understood that night.
Flags flew at half mast on Scottish Government buildings, the St Andrew’s Day celebrations planned for George Square were cancelled, and services were held at St Andrew’s Cathedral and Glasgow Cathedral. The Prince of Wales visited the scene on 6 December, and in January 2014 a series of fundraising events was held for the families of those who died and for the emergency services.
The air accident investigation
The Air Accidents Investigation Branch found no fault in the engines or gearbox. Both engines had flamed out because the two small supply tanks feeding them had run dry, even though usable fuel remained in the main tank. The fuel transfer pumps, which move fuel from the main tank to the supply tanks, had been switched off, for reasons the investigators could not establish. Low fuel warnings had been triggered, and the helicopter had not landed within the ten minutes that the procedures required. After the engines stopped, a successful autorotation and landing was not achieved.
The helicopter carried no flight data or cockpit voice recorder, which limited what could be learned. The AAIB’s final report, published in October 2015, made several safety recommendations, and the Civil Aviation Authority later required police helicopters to be fitted with flight recorders.
The fatal accident inquiry
A fatal accident inquiry opened on 8 April 2019 in a temporary courtroom at Hampden Park, before Sheriff Principal Craig Turnbull. His determination, published on 30 October 2019, found that the crash was caused by the engines flaming out through fuel starvation, because the pilot had not ensured that at least one fuel transfer pump switch was on, and that the pilot had not followed the checklist for the low fuel warnings. He identified two reasonable precautions that might have prevented the deaths, one of them an alert to warn crews when both transfer pumps are off. He made no recommendations.
The inquiry did not answer the question that many families most wanted answered: why an experienced pilot had acted as he did. Some relatives were critical of the findings, and of the six years it had taken to reach them. No criminal charges were brought.
The Clutha since
The Clutha partly reopened in July 2015, and the First Minister, Nicola Sturgeon, attended its reopening. Its outside walls have since been painted with murals of famous faces, and the pub continues to host live music and to mark each anniversary. Plans announced in 2023 for a new building on the site included a permanent memorial to the ten. The pub’s name is the old name for the River Clyde, and it now carries a meaning no one would have chosen. The crash is remembered among Glasgow’s disasters, and above all through the ten people who did not come home.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 29 November 2013, 8.45pm | Police helicopter takes off from Glasgow City Heliport |
| 29 November 2013, 10.22pm | Helicopter crashes onto the Clutha |
| 1 December 2013 | St Andrew’s Day events in George Square cancelled |
| 12 December 2013 | Tenth victim dies in hospital |
| February 2014 | AAIB special bulletin reports both engines flamed out |
| July 2015 | The Clutha partly reopens |
| October 2015 | AAIB final report published |
| 8 April 2019 | Fatal accident inquiry opens at Hampden Park |
| 30 October 2019 | Sheriff Principal’s determination published |
| November 2023 | Tenth anniversary marked across Glasgow |
Related questions
What happened at the Clutha?
On 29 November 2013 a Police Scotland helicopter crashed onto the roof of the Clutha pub on Stockwell Street at about 10.22pm, killing ten people and injuring more than thirty.
Who died in the Clutha crash?
The pilot David Traill, PC Kirsty Nelis and PC Tony Collins, and seven people in the pub: Gary Arthur, Joe Cusker, Colin Gibson, Robert Jenkins, John McGarrigle, Samuel McGhee and Mark O’Prey.
Why did the helicopter crash?
Both engines flamed out through fuel starvation. The fuel transfer pumps had been switched off, and the low fuel warnings were not acted on within the time the procedures required.
What did the fatal accident inquiry find?
Its determination of October 2019 found that the pilot had not followed the low fuel checklist. It identified two reasonable precautions but made no recommendations.