The victim
Marion Gilchrist, December 1908
Convicted
Oscar Slater, May 1909
Imprisoned
Peterhead, until 1927
Quashed
July 1928

On the evening of 21 December 1908 Marion Gilchrist, a wealthy woman in her eighties, was beaten to death in her flat on West Princes Street in the few minutes her maid was out of the house. Her murder was never solved. Instead, Glasgow convicted an innocent man, Oscar Slater, on evidence so weak and so coloured by prejudice that the case became Scotland’s most famous miscarriage of justice. He spent more than eighteen years in prison before he was freed, and the campaign to clear him helped to give Scotland a criminal appeal court.

The murder in West Princes Street

Marion Gilchrist lived at 49 West Princes Street, in a respectable terrace in the west end, with a single maid, Helen Lambie. She kept a large collection of jewellery hidden in her flat, worth about £3,000 at the time. Shortly before seven o’clock that evening Lambie went out for about ten minutes to buy a newspaper. While she was gone a neighbour in the flat below heard knocking and went up to investigate. When Lambie returned the two of them were at the door when a man walked calmly out of the flat and past them down the stairs. Inside, Marion Gilchrist lay dying from savage blows to the head.

The intruder had searched her papers but had taken only a single diamond brooch, leaving the rest of the jewellery behind. The descriptions given by Lambie and the neighbour were vague and did not agree with each other, and a fourteen-year-old girl in the street gave a description of a man running away that differed again.

Marion Gilchrist

Too often the story is told without its victim. Marion Gilchrist came from a prosperous Glasgow family, had never married and was in her eighties when she died. She lived quietly and comfortably in West Princes Street with her maid, kept a large collection of jewellery and was known to be cautious about security. She had relatives in the city with whom her relations were not always easy.

The details of the crime puzzled investigators from the start. Whoever killed her had searched among her private papers rather than taking the jewellery that lay within reach, and the man who walked past her neighbour and her maid on the stairs did not behave like a frightened burglar. Many later writers, beginning with the evidence that Detective Lieutenant Trench tried to bring forward, have suggested that the killer may have been someone she knew, looking for a document rather than for jewels. No one else was ever charged, and those theories remain unproven.

The wrong man

Oscar Slater had been born Oskar Leschziner in 1872 in Upper Silesia, then part of Germany, to a Jewish family. He had lived in London, Edinburgh and New York and by 1908 was living in Glasgow with his partner. He made his living from gambling and dealing in jewellery and sometimes described himself as a dentist. He was exactly the kind of man that respectable Edwardian Glasgow distrusted.

Days after the murder the police learned that Slater had been trying to sell a pawn ticket for a diamond brooch, and that he had left Glasgow for New York on 26 December. To the police, it looked like flight. Within days they discovered that the brooch had been pawned weeks before the murder and had nothing to do with the case. It should have been the end of their interest. Instead, they applied for his extradition. Slater, advised that he could fight it, chose to return to Scotland voluntarily to clear his name.

The trial

Slater was tried for murder at the High Court in Edinburgh in May 1909. The identification evidence was the heart of the case and it was deeply flawed. Witnesses who had seen a man only briefly, or not at all, identified Slater. Some had been shown his photograph before identifying him, and at one identity parade he was the only foreign-looking man, standing among off-duty police officers. Witnesses for the defence supported his alibi and confirmed that he had announced his trip to America long before the murder.

The judge, Lord Guthrie, made matters worse in his charge to the jury, dwelling on Slater’s disreputable way of life as if it were evidence of guilt. The jury convicted by a majority: nine voted guilty, five not proven and one not guilty. Under Scots law the majority was enough. Slater was sentenced to death.

His solicitors organised a petition, which gathered some 20,000 signatures, and less than two days before the date fixed for the execution the Secretary for Scotland commuted the sentence to penal servitude for life. Slater was sent to Peterhead prison in Aberdeenshire, where he spent the next eighteen and a half years breaking granite.

The campaign

Doubts about the conviction began almost at once. In 1910 the Edinburgh lawyer and criminologist William Roughead published an account of the trial that exposed its weaknesses. In 1912 Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, the creator of Sherlock Holmes, published The Case of Oscar Slater, a powerful argument for Slater’s innocence, and he kept up the pressure for the next sixteen years. His papers on the case are now held by Glasgow City Archives in the Mitchell Library.

The bravest act in the whole affair came from inside the Glasgow police. In 1914 Detective Lieutenant John Thomson Trench gave evidence to an inquiry that information pointing away from Slater, including the naming of a different man by a witness, had been withheld at the trial. The inquiry upheld the conviction. Trench was dismissed from the force and later prosecuted on unrelated charges, of which he was acquitted. He died in 1919, aged fifty, without seeing Slater cleared.

Slater received surprisingly little public support from Glasgow’s Jewish community, which seems to have feared that the notoriety of the case would fuel antisemitism. The prejudice he faced was real: the newspapers and the courtroom had repeatedly drawn attention to his foreignness and his religion.

Freedom and the appeal

In 1925 a message from Slater was smuggled out of Peterhead by a released prisoner, renewing the campaign. In 1927 the journalist William Park published The Truth about Oscar Slater, and public opinion turned decisively. Slater was released in November 1927.

Release was not the same as being cleared. Scotland had created a Court of Criminal Appeal only in 1926, and it could not hear cases decided before then. Parliament passed a special act, the Criminal Appeal (Scotland) Act 1927, to allow earlier convictions to be appealed, and in July 1928 the court quashed Slater’s conviction on the ground that the judge had misdirected the jury about the relevance of his character. Slater received £6,000 in compensation, a sum many thought paltry for nearly nineteen years of his life. He fell out publicly with Conan Doyle over the cost of the campaign.

Later life

Slater settled in Ayr, married, and repaired and sold antiques. When the Second World War began he and his wife were briefly interned as enemy aliens, despite his long years in Britain. Most of his family in Germany, including his sisters, were murdered in the Holocaust. He died in Ayr on 31 January 1948.

The case’s legacy

The Slater case became a standard lesson in the dangers of identification evidence, prejudice and institutional self-protection, and it was still being cited in official reviews of identity parades in the 1970s. Its most lasting effect was on the system itself: the campaign to free Slater was one of the forces behind the creation of Scotland’s criminal appeal court, through which every appeal against conviction in Scotland now passes. It even entered Glasgow speech, where see you Oscar was once rhyming slang for see you later. Other Glasgow verdicts that have been seriously doubted include the conviction of Peter Queen in 1932 and that of Paddy Meehan, who was pardoned in 1976.

The one thing the case never produced was justice for Marion Gilchrist. Nobody else was ever charged with her murder, and who killed her remains unknown. Her case is the last of the four in Jack House’s Square Mile of Murder, alongside Madeleine Smith, the Sandyford Place murder and Dr Pritchard.

Timeline

The Slater case: key dates
DateEvent
21 Dec 1908Marion Gilchrist is murdered at 49 West Princes Street
26 Dec 1908Slater sails for New York
1909Slater returns voluntarily to Scotland
May 1909Convicted by a majority in Edinburgh and sentenced to death
May 1909Sentence commuted to penal servitude for life
1910William Roughead publishes his account of the trial
1912Conan Doyle publishes The Case of Oscar Slater
1914Detective Lieutenant John Trench gives evidence to an inquiry; he is later dismissed
1919Trench dies
1926Scotland’s Court of Criminal Appeal is created
November 1927Slater is released from Peterhead
July 1928The appeal court quashes his conviction
31 Jan 1948Slater dies in Ayr
Was Oscar Slater guilty?

No. His conviction for the 1908 murder of Marion Gilchrist was quashed by the Court of Criminal Appeal in July 1928, and he is regarded as the victim of one of Scotland’s worst miscarriages of justice.

How long was Oscar Slater in prison?

He was convicted in May 1909 and released in November 1927, spending more than eighteen years in Peterhead prison.

What did Arthur Conan Doyle do for Oscar Slater?

Conan Doyle published The Case of Oscar Slater in 1912 and campaigned for his release and for his name to be cleared for the next sixteen years.

Who killed Marion Gilchrist?

Nobody knows. Nobody other than Slater was ever charged, and the murder remains unsolved.