Between January 1956 and January 1958 Peter Manuel killed at least seven people in Glasgow and Lanarkshire, and he is strongly suspected of two further murders. Their names belong at the start of any account of him: Anne Kneilands, aged seventeen; Marion Watt, her daughter Vivienne, sixteen, and her sister Margaret Brown; Isabelle Cooke, seventeen; and Peter and Doris Smart and their young son Michael. For two years, as the killings went unsolved, families across the eastern edge of Glasgow locked their doors at night and walked their daughters home.
Manuel was convicted of seven murders at the High Court in Glasgow in May 1958 and hanged at Barlinnie on 11 July 1958. His trial, in which he dismissed his lawyers and defended himself, became the most sensational in modern Scottish history. This page tells the story through the record of the case and keeps its focus on the people he killed and on the innocent man who was blamed for his crimes.
A criminal from childhood
Peter Thomas Anthony Manuel was born in New York on 15 March 1927 to Scottish parents who had emigrated in search of work. The family returned to Scotland in 1932, moved to Coventry for some years, and after their home there was destroyed in the bombing of 1940 settled in the Lanarkshire village of Birkenshaw, near Uddingston, where his father became a local councillor.
Manuel was committing crimes from the age of nine. He passed through approved schools, borstals and prisons in England and Scotland for burglary and theft, and as a teenager he began to attack women. In 1946, at the High Court in Glasgow, he was sentenced to eight years for rape, and he served most of the sentence at Peterhead. Released in 1952, he soon returned to housebreaking. In 1955, after a broken engagement, he attacked a young woman near his home; tried at Airdrie, he conducted his own defence, and the jury returned a verdict of not proven. To those who knew him he was a liar, a fantasist and a small-time thief who wanted to be thought important.
Anne Kneilands
On 2 January 1956 Anne Kneilands, a seventeen-year-old machinist from East Kilbride, set out to meet a young man for a date. He did not keep the appointment. Two days later her body was found near a golf course at Capelrig, on the edge of East Kilbride. She had been chased across fields and beaten to death. Manuel, who was working nearby for the Scottish Gas Board, had fresh scratches on his face and was questioned, but there was no evidence to charge him.
Burnside and the ordeal of William Watt
In the early hours of 17 September 1956 a gunman broke into a bungalow in Burnside, near Rutherglen, and shot dead Marion Watt, aged 45, her sixteen-year-old daughter Vivienne and her sister Margaret Brown as they lay in bed. The family’s daily help found them later that morning. Marion’s husband, William Watt, was away on a fishing holiday at Lochgilphead in Argyll.
The police came to suspect William Watt. Witnesses claimed to have seen him driving through the night, and the theory took hold that he had driven back to Burnside, killed his family and returned to his hotel before dawn. On 27 September he was arrested and remanded in Barlinnie. He spent more than two months there, grieving for his wife and daughter while publicly suspected of killing them, before he was released in December for lack of evidence. Many in the city continued to doubt him.
By a grim coincidence Manuel himself was in Barlinnie that autumn, serving eighteen months for a break-in at a colliery canteen. From his cell he wrote to Watt’s solicitor, Laurence Dowdall, offering information about the murders, and in interviews he described the inside of the Watt house in detail he said had come from another criminal. Dowdall became convinced that Manuel was the killer and told the police, but there was not enough evidence to act.
The winter of 1957 to 1958
Manuel was released at the end of November 1957. On 8 December a Newcastle taxi driver, Sydney Dunn, was shot and his throat cut on a lonely moorland road in County Durham at a time when Manuel was in the north-east of England for a job interview. Manuel was never tried for that killing, which took place outside Scottish jurisdiction, but he remains the main suspect.
On 28 December Isabelle Cooke, a seventeen-year-old Sunday school teacher from Mount Vernon, left home to go to a dance at Uddingston Grammar School. She never arrived. Her belongings were found scattered across the area in the following days, but her body could not be found.
In the early hours of New Year’s Day 1958 Manuel broke into the home of Peter and Doris Smart in Sheepburn Road, Uddingston, and shot all three members of the family in their beds. Over the following days he returned to the house, ate food from the family’s table and took their car, which was later found abandoned in the Gorbals. The bodies were not discovered until 6 January.
The banknotes
The case was broken by careful police work. Peter Smart had withdrawn a sum of money in new five pound notes from his bank in Parkhead on the last day of 1957, and the bank could supply the serial numbers. Detectives learned from an informant that Manuel, who had been without money at Hogmanay, had been spending freely in East End pubs in the days afterwards. Notes he had used were recovered and matched to those issued to Peter Smart.
Manuel was arrested at his parents’ home on 14 January 1958. His father was also arrested over stolen goods found in the house. Manuel offered to confess in return for his father’s release, and in the presence of his parents he admitted the murders. He then led detectives to a field at Burntbroom Farm, near Mount Vernon, where Isabelle Cooke was buried, and showed them where in the Clyde he had thrown the guns used in the Watt and Smart murders. Divers recovered both weapons, and ballistic tests confirmed his account.
The trial
The trial opened at the High Court in Glasgow on 12 May 1958 before Lord Cameron, with Manuel charged with eight murders. He pleaded not guilty and claimed that his confessions had been forced from him. Early in the trial William Watt gave evidence, and his solicitor described his prison conversations with the accused.
On 22 May Manuel sacked his counsel and conducted the rest of his defence himself. He recalled and cross-examined witnesses, including William Watt, whom he accused of the Burnside murders, and he made a closing speech lasting about two and a half hours. The judge remarked on the skill with which he had conducted his case. It made no difference. The trial lasted fourteen days, with 169 witnesses and 158 productions.
On 26 May 1958 the jury convicted him of seven murders. The judge had directed them to acquit him of the murder of Anne Kneilands, because there was no evidence to corroborate his confession, a requirement of Scots law. Under the Homicide Act 1957, six of the murders, committed by shooting, were capital murders, and Manuel was sentenced to death.
Execution
His appeal was heard and rejected on 24 June 1958. He was hanged at Barlinnie at one minute past eight on the morning of 11 July 1958 and buried, as the law required, in an unmarked grave within the prison walls. When the prison’s old execution block was demolished in the 1990s, the remains of those executed there were exhumed and reburied elsewhere.
What the case left behind
The case left lasting lessons. The treatment of William Watt, an innocent and bereaved man held for more than two months on mistaken evidence, became a warning about the dangers of a police investigation fixing too early on the obvious suspect. Laurence Dowdall’s persistence showed how much depended on one solicitor willing to trust his own judgement. And the painstaking tracing of a handful of banknotes demonstrated the patient detective work that finally ended the killings.
Manuel has been the subject of books, documentaries and television drama, and he is sometimes still discussed as though he were a clever and fascinating figure. The record does not support that view. He was a lifelong criminal of no particular intelligence who caused enormous suffering, and the real story of the case belongs to those he killed and to the families who survived them. More of the cases that shaped Scottish justice are gathered on our famous crimes page.
Timeline
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 15 March 1927 | Born in New York |
| 1946 | Sentenced to eight years for rape |
| 2 Jan 1956 | Anne Kneilands is murdered near East Kilbride |
| 17 Sept 1956 | Marion Watt, Vivienne Watt and Margaret Brown are shot dead in Burnside |
| 27 Sept 1956 | William Watt is arrested and remanded in Barlinnie |
| December 1956 | William Watt is released |
| 8 Dec 1957 | Taxi driver Sydney Dunn is murdered in County Durham |
| 28 Dec 1957 | Isabelle Cooke disappears on her way to a dance |
| 1 Jan 1958 | Peter, Doris and Michael Smart are shot dead in Uddingston |
| 14 Jan 1958 | Manuel is arrested |
| 12 May 1958 | Trial opens at the High Court in Glasgow |
| 26 May 1958 | Convicted of seven murders and sentenced to death |
| 11 July 1958 | Hanged at Barlinnie |
Related questions
How many people did Peter Manuel kill?
He was convicted of seven murders in 1958. He confessed to an eighth, of Anne Kneilands, but the judge directed an acquittal on that charge for lack of corroboration, and he is also the main suspect in the murder of Sydney Dunn in County Durham.
Who was William Watt?
The husband and father of three of Manuel’s victims in Burnside. He was wrongly arrested and held in Barlinnie for more than two months in 1956 before being released.
Did Peter Manuel defend himself?
Yes. On 22 May 1958, part way through his trial at the High Court in Glasgow, he dismissed his lawyers and conducted the rest of his defence himself.
When was Peter Manuel hanged?
He was hanged at Barlinnie Prison at 8.01am on 11 July 1958, after his appeal was rejected on 24 June.