1813
Body snatching at the Ramshorn
1857 to 1908
The square mile of murder
1909 and 1984
Two great miscarriages of justice
This section’s rule
Victims first, facts over legend

Every great city has its dark shelf of famous cases. Glasgow’s is distinctive for how many of its best known crimes turned out to be stories about justice itself: about the uniquely Scottish verdict of not proven, about wrongful convictions and the long campaigns to overturn them, about crimes that were never solved and the people they left behind. This page is a guide to those cases, from the body snatchers of the early nineteenth century to the gangland trials of the 1990s, with links to the full story of each.

The pages in this section follow a simple rule. The victims come first, what was never proven is never asserted as fact, and the legends that have grown up around violent men are tested against the record.

The body snatchers, 1813

In the early nineteenth century Glasgow’s medical schools needed far more bodies for dissection than the law allowed, and the city’s graveyards were raided by night. In December 1813 the body of Janet McAlister was stolen from the Ramshorn churchyard, and remains were found in the College Street anatomy rooms of Granville Sharp Pattison. A crowd attacked the anatomy professor’s house, and Pattison and his colleagues were tried in Edinburgh in 1814. The verdict was not proven. Read the full story in Glasgow’s body snatchers.

The square mile of murder, 1857 to 1908

In 1961 the journalist Jack House wrote about four notorious cases that took place within about a square mile of the west end, between Blythswood Hill and Charing Cross. The first was the trial of Madeleine Smith, the Blythswood Square architect’s daughter accused in 1857 of poisoning her lover with arsenic. The jury’s verdict of not proven made her case the most famous illustration of Scotland’s third verdict, which was finally abolished for new trials from 1 January 2026.

The second was the Sandyford Place murder of 1862, in which the servant Jessie McPherson was killed and her friend Jessie McLachlan was sentenced to death after a trial that many believed was unfair; public outcry saved her life. The third was the case of Dr Edward Pritchard, who poisoned his wife and mother-in-law in 1865 and became the last person hanged in public in Glasgow. The fourth was the murder of Marion Gilchrist in 1908, which led to the conviction of Oscar Slater.

Oscar Slater, 1909 to 1928

The Slater case is Scotland’s best known miscarriage of justice. A German Jewish immigrant was convicted of murder in 1909 on unreliable identification evidence and prejudice, sentenced to death and reprieved, and spent more than eighteen years in Peterhead before a campaign supported by Arthur Conan Doyle won his release and the quashing of his conviction in 1928. The case helped to create Scotland’s criminal appeal court. Marion Gilchrist’s killer was never found.

The gallows at Duke Street

After public executions ended, Glasgow’s condemned prisoners were hanged inside prison walls. Twelve people were executed at Duke Street Prison between 1902 and 1928, among them Susan Newell, hanged in 1923 for the murder of a thirteen-year-old newspaper boy and the last woman executed in Scotland. Duke Street also held suffragettes on hunger strike before the First World War.

The razor gangs and the Gorbals Vampire

Between the wars the razor gangs, above all the Billy Boys and the Norman Conks, gave Glasgow an international reputation for violence, until Chief Constable Percy Sillitoe broke them in the 1930s. Not every famous Glasgow case involved a crime at all. In September 1954 hundreds of children stormed the Southern Necropolis to hunt the Gorbals Vampire, a creature with iron teeth that existed only in playground rumour, and the panic helped to bring about a new law on horror comics.

Peter Manuel, 1956 to 1958

Peter Manuel murdered at least seven people in Glasgow and Lanarkshire between 1956 and 1958, while an innocent man, William Watt, was held in prison for the murder of his own wife, daughter and sister-in-law. Manuel defended himself at his trial in 1958 and was hanged at Barlinnie that July.

Bible John, 1968 to 1969

Between February 1968 and October 1969 three young women, Patricia Docker, Jemima McDonald and Helen Puttock, were murdered after nights out dancing, at least two of them after evenings at the Barrowland Ballroom. A newspaper named the suspected killer Bible John. The murders have never been solved, and doubts have grown about whether a single killer was responsible.

The Ice Cream Wars, 1984

In the housing schemes of the East End in the early 1980s, rivalry over ice cream van routes, which were also used to sell stolen goods and drugs, escalated into violence. On 16 April 1984 a fire at a flat in Ruchazie killed six members of the Doyle family, including a baby of eighteen months. Two men were convicted, but twenty years later their convictions were quashed as a miscarriage of justice. The murders of the Doyle family remain unsolved. The full story is on our Ice Cream Wars page.

Thompson and Ferris, 1991 to 1992

In August 1991 Arthur Thompson junior, son of the man the press called the Godfather of Glasgow, Arthur Thompson, was shot dead near the family home. On the day of his funeral the bodies of Robert Glover and Joe Hanlon were found in a car on the route of the funeral procession. Paul Ferris, a former Thompson enforcer, was tried for the murder in 1992 in what was then the longest and most expensive criminal trial in Scottish history, and was acquitted of every charge. None of the three killings has ever been solved. Ferris died in October 2026.

Scotland’s third verdict

A remarkable number of these cases turned on the not proven verdict. For centuries Scottish juries could choose between three verdicts: guilty, not guilty and not proven. Not proven had the same legal effect as not guilty, since the accused walked free and could not be tried again for the same crime, but it was widely understood to mean that the jury suspected guilt without being sure. Granville Sharp Pattison in 1814 and Madeleine Smith in 1857 both left court with that verdict.

Critics argued that the verdict was confusing for juries, unfair to accused people who were left under a cloud, and distressing for victims and their families. After years of debate the Scottish Parliament passed the Victims, Witnesses, and Justice Reform (Scotland) Act 2025, which abolished it. Since 1 January 2026 juries in new criminal trials in Scotland have had a choice of two verdicts only.

Where the cases happened

Many of these stories can be traced on the map of the modern city. The Ramshorn burying ground still stands on Ingram Street in the Merchant City. Blythswood Square, Sauchiehall Street, Sandyford Place and West Princes Street, the settings of the four Victorian cases, lie within a short walk of each other between the city centre and Charing Cross. The Southern Necropolis, scene of the vampire hunt, is on Caledonia Road. The High Court still sits in the Saltmarket facing Glasgow Green, where the crowds gathered for the last public hanging. Other places have changed beyond recognition: the site of Duke Street Prison is now housing, and the streets of the old Gorbals and the Calton where the razor gangs fought have largely been rebuilt.

How the story changes

Glasgow’s crime history does not only consist of violence. It includes the creation of one of Britain’s first modern police forces, told on our City of Glasgow Police page, the busy courts described on our Sheriff Court page, and, most recently, a dramatic fall in violence. From 2005 the Violence Reduction Unit began treating violence as a public health problem, and over the following decade the city’s homicide rate fell by more than half. That story is told on our page about the Calton Tongs and the young teams.

Not every story here is about street violence. The fraud behind the collapse of the City of Glasgow Bank in 1878 ruined more families than any gang, and some Glasgow-born criminals won their notoriety far from the city, among them the Victorian poisoner Thomas Neill Cream.

A final word on tone. For a century Glasgow’s crime stories have been sold as entertainment, usually at the expense of the districts and families involved. The pages in this section tell these cases because they mattered: to the law, to the city and above all to the people whose lives they ended or changed.

Timeline

Glasgow’s famous cases at a glance
DateEvent
1813 to 1814Body snatching at the Ramshorn; Pattison case not proven
1857Madeleine Smith tried for murder; not proven
1862Sandyford Place murder; Jessie McLachlan convicted, later reprieved
1865Dr Pritchard convicted and hanged in public
1908 to 1928Murder of Marion Gilchrist; Oscar Slater wrongly convicted, then cleared
1923Susan Newell hanged at Duke Street
1920s and 1930sThe razor gangs; Sillitoe’s crackdown
1954The Gorbals Vampire hunt
1956 to 1958Peter Manuel’s murders; hanged at Barlinnie
1968 to 1969The Bible John murders, unsolved
1984The Doyle family fire; convictions quashed in 2004
1991 to 1992Murder of Arthur Thompson junior; Paul Ferris acquitted
2005The Violence Reduction Unit is founded
What are Glasgow’s most famous crimes?

They include the Madeleine Smith poisoning trial of 1857, the Sandyford Place murder of 1862, Dr Pritchard’s poisonings in 1865, the Oscar Slater case, the Peter Manuel murders, the Bible John murders and the Ice Cream Wars.

What was the square mile of murder?

A phrase coined by the journalist Jack House for four notorious murders committed between 1857 and 1908 within about a square mile of Glasgow’s west end, between Blythswood Hill and Charing Cross.

Which famous Glasgow murders are unsolved?

The murders of Marion Gilchrist in 1908, the three Bible John victims in 1968 and 1969, the Doyle family in 1984, and Arthur Thompson junior, Robert Glover and Joe Hanlon in 1991 have never been solved.

What was the last public hanging in Glasgow?

Dr Edward Pritchard was hanged in public in Jail Square, facing Glasgow Green, on 28 July 1865.